FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) vs Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU)
Smart plugs · For Europe
- Both work with Home Assistant.
- The Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works with Apple Home, Google Home, Amazon Alexa and SmartThings; for the FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) it isn't confirmed.
- They also differ on: Matter, radio, hub required, local control and max load.
Side by side
| Fact | FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) | Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) |
|---|---|---|
| Matter | Unconfirmed | Yes, over Wi-Fi[2],[5],[7] |
| Apple Home | Unconfirmed | Via Matter[4],[5] |
| Google Home | Unconfirmed | Via Matter[1],[5] |
| Amazon Alexa | Unconfirmed | Via Matter[1],[5] |
| SmartThings | Unconfirmed | Via Matter[4],[5] |
| Home Assistant | Via FRITZ!Box[6] | Yes[6] |
| Radio | Unconfirmed | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth[2] |
| Hub required | Yes[1],[3],[4] | No[2],[3] |
| Local control | Unconfirmed[5],[6] | Yes[3],[6] |
| Energy monitoring | Yes[1],[3] | Yes[1],[2] |
| Max load | 2,300 W[2],[3] | 2,500 W[2] |
A bar on the left marks the rows where they differ. Numbers in brackets lead to the source on each device's own page, which also has the notes and what to check before you buy. Checked against official sources; the older of the two records was verified on . How we verify.
Quick answers
- FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) or Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU): which works with Apple Home?
- Confirmed only for the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU). The FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) isn't confirmed either way; the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works through Matter. More smart plugs for Apple Home
- FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) or Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU): which works with Google Home?
- Confirmed only for the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU). The FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) isn't confirmed either way; the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works through Matter. More smart plugs for Google Home
- FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) or Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU): which works with Amazon Alexa?
- Confirmed only for the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU). The FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) isn't confirmed either way; the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works through Matter. More smart plugs for Amazon Alexa
- FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) or Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU): which works with SmartThings?
- Confirmed only for the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU). The FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) isn't confirmed either way; the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works through Matter. More smart plugs for SmartThings
- FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) or Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU): which works with Home Assistant?
- Both. The FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) works through the FRITZ!Box; the Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU) works directly. More smart plugs for Home Assistant
Full details and sources: FRITZ!DECT 200 (EU) · Shelly Plug S Gen3 (EU)